Justice Gavai Recuses Himself from Hearing Former Mumbai Police Commissioner Param Bir Singh’s Case in SC

SUPREME Court judge, Justice BR Gavai, Tuesday recused himself from hearing a plea filed by former Mumbai police commissioner Param Bir Singh seeking to transfer all inquiries against him to an independent agency outside Maharashtra because of what he alleged was a witch-hunt against him by the state government.

The matter was listed before a vacation bench of Justices Vineet Saran and BR Gavai.

At the outset of the hearing, Justice Saran, who was heading the bench, told senior advocate Puneet Bali that Justice Gavai had some difficulty in taking up this matter.

“I can’t hear this matter”, Justice Gavai said.

The bench thus directed the matter to be listed next week before a bench of which Justice Gavai is not part.

Senior advocate Puneet Bali, appearing for Singh, said the inquiries against his client were a “complete witch-hunt” and in “complete transgression” of the orders passed by the apex court as well as the Bombay High Court.

Singh is facing both a departmental inquiry as well as a police case. He has alleged that the inquiry officer of the state government had threatened to foist false cases on him unless his complaint against former Home Minister Anil Deshmukh was withdrawn.

Also Read: Maha tells Bombay HC it won’t arrest Param Bir Singh in the corruption case till May 20

The investigation against Singh arose from an FIR filed in Akola by Inspector Bhimrao Ghadge against Singh. The FIR was transferred to Thane for investigation. Ghadge made a series of allegations of corruption against Singh and other officers. These allegations pertain to the period when Singh was posted with the Thane police.

Earlier, Singh had alleged corruption against Deshmukh that led to an order for a CBI probe against the latter by the Bombay High Court. Deshmukh had to step down as state home minister.

The article was originally published in The Leaflet.